From What's Wrong with You to What's Strong in You
How trauma informed leaders move from judgment to context strengths and practical support

“What’s wrong with you?”
Most of us have heard that question. Sometimes someone says it directly. Sometimes it appears in a performance conversation, a classroom, a courtroom, a family meeting, or the story we tell ourselves about another person. Even when no one says the words, the judgment is clear.
The question starts with a conclusion: the person is the problem.
Trauma informed leadership asks us to slow down and become curious. Instead of beginning with “What’s wrong with you?” we ask “What happened to you?” or “What is happening around you?” Those questions give us context. They help us understand how stress, loss, trauma, relationships, workplace conditions, and missing support may be shaping what we see.
Context matters, but I believe leaders need to take the shift further. We also need to ask: “What’s strong in you?”

Labels Change What Leaders Can See
Traditional leadership often describes people through deficits. An employee is difficult. A student is defiant. A colleague is negative. A client is resistant. Once a label takes hold, it can become the lens through which every future interaction is interpreted.
That lens affects expectations. It influences who receives patience, who is invited into decisions, whose concerns are taken seriously, and who is seen as capable of growth.
It also creates defensiveness. When someone repeatedly tells me what is wrong with me, my attention goes toward proving the label false. I am less able to hear feedback, consider another perspective, or participate in problem solving. Shame narrows the conversation before it has a chance to become productive.
A human centered lens does not remove responsibility. It helps us understand the person and the conditions around the behavior well enough to respond effectively.

Move Through Four Better Questions
Leaders can use four questions to move from judgment toward useful action.
What Are We Labeling
Name the word being used. Is the person being called stubborn, negative, difficult, distracted, unmotivated, or resistant? A label can feel like an explanation even when it tells us very little about what is happening.
What Happened or Is Happening
Look for context. What pressure is the person carrying? What expectations were unclear? What support was unavailable? Has the person experienced repeated change, broken trust, inconsistent leadership, or a lack of safety? Curiosity is not an excuse for harmful behavior. It gives leaders information they need to respond with clarity.
What Is Strong Here
Look beneath the behavior for a capacity that may be poorly directed, unsupported, or easy to miss. Stubbornness may include persistence. Pushback may reflect courage or attention to risk. Distractibility may coexist with creativity and an ability to see connections. What looks like resistance may reflect caution, a desire for stability, or experience with previous changes that caused harm.
This is not an invitation to turn every concern into a compliment. It is an effort to see the whole person instead of reducing someone to the quality that frustrates us most.
What Support or Conditions Are Missing
This final question turns a compassionate reframe into implementation. If a person has a useful strength, what would help them apply it effectively? They may need clearer expectations, a better feedback process, role clarity, coaching, supervision, a reliable way to raise concerns, or boundaries around unacceptable conduct. Sometimes the organization must change a workload, workflow, policy, or communication practice that keeps producing the same conflict.
Training individuals to use better language will not be enough if the surrounding system continues to punish questions, ignore concerns, reward overwork, or communicate inconsistently.

Behavior Can Be Communication
One idea from the Mindful Management podcast episode on this topic deserves special attention: defiance can be communication waiting to be understood.
That does not mean every behavior is acceptable. Leaders still need to address harm, performance concerns, and missed expectations. But behavior gives us information. Before deciding that someone does not care, a leader can ask what the person may be trying to protect, communicate, avoid, or change.
In a school district, teachers described a student as defiant. The behavior was real and disruptive. When the adults paused, they also recognized persistence, self advocacy, and problem solving. Seeing those strengths changed how they related to the student. Frustration made room for curiosity, and the student had a better opportunity to thrive.
The same dynamic appears in workplaces. In one nonprofit team, a staff member had been labeled negative because she regularly raised concerns. From an outside perspective, I could see that many of those concerns were valid. When her leader began treating that contribution as critical thinking, she became the person the team trusted to identify risk. The behavior did not disappear. Its value became visible and could be directed toward a useful role.
Strengths Improve Engagement
A strengths based approach is supported by workplace research.
Gallup reports that people who use their strengths every day are six times more likely to be engaged at work. Gallup also found that teams that focus on strengths every day have 12.5 percent greater productivity. These findings do not mean leaders should ignore skill gaps or performance problems. They show why development should include what people already do well and how those capacities can support the work.
When leaders focus only on weaknesses, employees learn that their value is conditional. When leaders recognize strengths and set clear expectations, people have a more useful foundation for feedback, growth, and accountability.
Ask How You Would Introduce Your Best Friend
One question has become especially useful in my own practice: How would I introduce this person if they were my best friend?
We know our closest friends are imperfect. We know their habits, mistakes, and rough edges. Yet if we introduced them to a room full of strangers, we would not begin with their worst quality. We would describe their humor, loyalty, creativity, determination, care, or courage. Their weaknesses still exist, but they are not the whole introduction.
Try applying that question to the employee, colleague, client, student, or community member who is difficult for you to understand. What becomes visible when the problem word is no longer the first thing you see?
Expectations Can Become Destinations
This work is personal for me. I spent five years in foster care. As I sat on courtroom benches and interacted with caseworkers and teachers, there was an expectation that I would eventually become my mother. I absorbed that expectation as if it were a prediction about my future.
When adults see a young person only through risk, family history, anger, or struggle, those expectations can narrow what the young person believes is possible. The same thing happens in organizations. People notice when leaders expect failure, conflict, or resistance from them.
Leaders help shape what receives attention. If we expect weakness, we will keep collecting evidence of weakness. If we learn to recognize strength, we create more opportunities for that strength to become useful.

Try This at Your Next Team Meeting
Before your next meeting, identify one problem word that has been used about a team member or group. Then work through these questions:
What observable behavior are we describing, without using a character judgment?
What may have happened, or what may be happening, that gives this behavior context?
What strength, need, value, or protective response might be underneath it?
What expectation still needs to be clear?
What support, boundary, workflow, or organizational condition needs to change?
You do not have to share every reframe aloud. Begin by holding a fuller picture in your own mind. Notice whether your tone changes, whether you ask better questions, and whether the conversation becomes more productive.
Human Centered Leadership Sees the Whole Person
Human centered leadership does not ask us to pretend that every behavior is harmless or every person is performing well. It asks us to see the human beneath the behavior and to understand enough context to respond responsibly.
“What’s wrong with you?” keeps people inside a fixed story. “What happened to you?” adds context. “What’s strong in you?” restores capacity. “What support or conditions are missing?” moves the organization toward implementation.
That sequence gives leaders a more complete way to hold accountability, dignity, and change at the same time.

Next Step
If your organization is ready to move beyond trauma informed language and into daily leadership, communication, supervision, and decision-making practices, explore Chefalo Consulting’s Training and Guided Learning or request a conversation.



Comments